Myths and Misconceptions About Child Support and Taxes
Myth: “Child support is tax deductible.”
Child support payments are never tax deductible. Federal law treats child support as a personal obligation, not a tax-adjustable expense.
Myth: “Child support counts as income.”
The IRS does not treat child support as taxable income, and the parent who receives support does not report it on their tax return.
Myth: “If I pay child support, I automatically get to claim the child.”
Payment does not determine tax rights. The child support order decides who may claim the child for tax purposes. The IRS usually accepts whichever parent files first unless both parents claim the child, in which case federal residency rules decide who receives the credit. If a parent files contrary to the order, the other parent may pursue contempt in Washington Superior Court.
Myth: “The parent with more parenting time always gets the Child Tax Credit.”
Not necessarily. If the child support order assigns the tax credit, both parents must follow it. The IRS does not check court orders and will only look at federal residency rules if both parents claim the child. If a parent claims the child contrary to the order, the other parent may enforce the order through contempt.
Myth: “If I pay for extracurriculars or medical bills, I should get to claim the child.”
Extra expenses do not determine tax rights. Only federal residency rules and the child support order determine who may claim the child.
Myth: “If the child support order says I claim the child, the IRS must honor it.”
Not automatically. The IRS follows federal rules and will not review the child support order unless there is a conflict. Even in a conflict, the IRS may require proof of residency rather than relying on the court order. Washington courts, not the IRS, enforce violations of the child support order.
Myth: “The IRS will enforce the child support order automatically.”
The IRS does not enforce Washington court orders. If both parents claim the child, the IRS applies federal tie-breaker rules under 26 U.S.C. § 152(c)(4). Washington courts handle violations through contempt.
Myth: “If the other parent refuses to sign Form 8332, I can still claim the child.”
If the child support order gives you the right to claim the child, you may enforce that order in state court. The IRS may deny the claim or audit both parents if the required documentation is not consistent.
Myth: “Arrears do not affect tax refunds.”
If a parent owes back child support, federal and state tax refunds can be intercepted and applied toward unpaid support before being issued.
Myth: “If both parents claim the child, the IRS will look at fairness.”
The IRS does not evaluate fairness. It applies a strict tie-breaker system based on where the child lived most of the year and each parent’s income. 26 U.S.C. § 152(c)(4).
Myth: “If I am behind on support, I lose all tax benefits automatically.”
Tax rights do not automatically disappear unless the child support order says so. However, arrears can lead to refund interception, and courts may reconsider future tax allocations during modification.
Myth: “Claiming a child improperly is tax fraud.”
Incorrect claims can trigger audits, penalties, or refund denials, but are rarely prosecuted as criminal fraud. The more serious consequence is contempt in Washington court for violating the child support order.
Myth: “Alternating the tax credit is not allowed.”
Washington courts commonly order parents to alternate tax years. The IRS accepts alternating arrangements as long as returns are filed consistently and no duplicate claims are made.
Myth: “If the order is silent, we can both claim the child.”
If the child support order does not assign tax rights, federal law awards the tax benefits to the parent the child lived with most of the year. Claiming the child improperly can trigger an IRS review or a contempt motion in state court.